Advice for Writers: How to Handle Rejection

06/20/09  Print this post Print this post    3 Comments   Popular   Written by Julie Schwietert
    Share
Becoming a professional writer means learning about how to handle rejection.

Photo: Brymo

So you want to be a writer.You’re disciplined enough to put pen to paper every day, you know the value of revision, and you’re confident you can craft a successful query or pitch.

But can you handle rejection?

Here are three tips to help you cope with inevitable rejections of your writing:

1. Don’t take it personally.

Writing is a huge part of your identity. It’s also the skill you’d like to ply in order to earn a decent living. But rejection of an article is not rejection of you as a person. Nor is a rejection a summary dismissal of the value of your entire body of work or your future writing.

The sooner you learn this lesson and apply it, the sooner you’ll be able to take advantage of these other tips.

2. Consider rejection a form of constructive feedback.

Photo: HandsLive

When you receive a rejection notice, sit with the disappointment for a few minutes. Then, step back from your immediate reaction and take a more analytical posture.

What information has the editor provided about the reasons why your piece was rejected? Now that you’re looking at the piece with fresh eyes, how might it have been stronger? What are its weaknesses? Does this piece really fit in the publication to which you submitted it?

If the editor did not offer any specific feedback (and there are many reasons why we don’t), consider responding with a brief, polite message thanking the editor for his or her time and asking the editor for any advice about future pitches and pieces.

3. Remember: Editors, like tastes, are subjective.

At Matador, we review upward of 50 submissions every week. We know by the end of the first paragraph whether a writer’s submission is likely to fit with the style, format, voice, and vision of our publication.

A rejection of your article doesn’t necessarily mean that you’re not a skilled writer. It often means your particular piece simply doesn’t fit the subjective scope of Matador’s publishing interests.

The same is true for every other publication.

Want to learn the craft of travel writing?

Sign up for Matador’s new Travel Writing School and get the skills you need.


    Share

About the Author

Julie Schwietert

Matador's Managing Editor Julie Schwietert Collazo is a prolific writer, editor, researcher, and translator who lives in New York, Mexico City, and San Juan. She has a BA in English and Women's Studies, a Masters of Social Work, and is working on a PhD in Literature at the Centro de Estudios Avanzados de Puerto Rico y el Caribe.

3 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Tim Patterson replied on June 22, 2009

    Good advice.

    ↵ Reply
  • JoAnna replied on October 19, 2009

    When I receive a rejection letter, if there’s any hint that an editor might be interested in my writing style (even though this particular pitch didn’t work out), I repitch another idea. Regardless, I always try to thank the editor if possible (it’s sometimes tough to do this through snail mail).

    ↵ Reply
  • Spencer Spellman replied on June 15, 2010

    I really like JoAnna’s comment. I sometimes just leave it be deciding on the tone and content of the rejection letter, but I recently got one and then repitched it with more success.

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:



Explore the Community



Popular Stories on Matador

Buenos Aires Binge Eating 101

We gave Tom Gates 24 hours to eat as much as he could s... 

Ultimate Burning Man Packing List: 50+ Items To Bring To BRC

The first step to a successful trip to

Photo Essay: People Watching in Verdi Square, New York City

The comings and goings of people at Verdi Square, in th... 

MatadorTV vlog 8

Live from the Pike Place Market in downtown Seattle.... 

Vote Zach To Take Over For Lady Oprah

A man, a wheelchair, a wig, and a dream. ... 

Abby Sunderland Lost and Found at Sea

16-year-old solo sailor makes it to shore safely after ... 

20 Best Beer Towns in America

. . . nothing wrong with choosing your next travel dest... 

10 Drink Recipes You Can Light On Fire

Put a shallow layer of 151-proof rum on top. Light the ... 

Why is it so Difficult to Talk About Death?

When it's your time to go, it's your time to go. ... 

Notes on Abuelo Colque

"Even New Years, standing with his sons drinking beer b... 



Focus





Editor Blogs