Notes on Two Rivers: Benares Through My Lens

08/24/09  Print this post Print this post    12 Comments   Popular   Written by Robert Hirschfield
  • Stumble It

Photo above by jpereira_net.

Robert Hirschfield looks at Benares through camera lenses, book pages, and the ceremonies surrounding life and death, no matter if you’re a person or a dog.

Michael, from County Kerry, feeds Runtlin Rimpoche antibiotics through a syringe. The puppy seems unsure whether it’s worth the effort. The steep fan of bones looks bigger than the dog.

We are at the Krishnamurti Center, upriver. Maybe in Benares a dog’s death is also auspicious. When his time comes, Runtlin Rimpoche will not be wrapped in saffron, set down upon logs and ignited. But he already operates in us as part of the death consciousness of Benares.

Sitting up in bed at dawn, I hear the peacocks screeching in the grass. (Krishnamurti is colonized by peacocks.) From the old Shiva temple on the hill across the wall, Vedic chants are gusting into my space.

This is my third time in Benares. I awake to the strange feeling of having been stolen by the timeless from my New York routine of interviews and story deadlines. I open a book by Krishnamurti. He tells me, “In the light of silence, all problems are dissolved.”

The words help. The words don’t help. Judith hides behind the words. Right before I left for India, a cancerous nodule was discovered in her left lung. She never comes with me to India. She has a fear of being disabled by bacteria. An abstract expressionist painter, when she travels, it is Vancouver to photograph the stones and bones on her friend’s island.

Photo by Ahron de Leeuw.

“Sarcomas,” said Dr. Ari Klapholtz, the distinguished pulmonologist who examined her, “are funky.”

This one, like her bone cancer three years ago, originated in Judith’s uterus. An offspring of her leiomyosarcoma, the nomadic cancer that wanders the bloodstream until latching on to a liver, a lung, the bone of a bone-obsessed artist.

I go down the hill to photograph the Ganges. Bathers have gotten there first. The air rings with the sounds of hacking, water slapping. Energy that belies the hour. I am forced to remind myself that the Ganges was once part of the toe of Vishnu, or the brow of Shiva. The accordion of Indian mythology opens lightly around this matter.

The boatmen, gray smudges in the gray light, look up at me from their boats, and ask, “Boat?” I say, “No,” and they ask, “Photo?” “Photo,” I agree, charmed by their deft movement from livelihood to the next best thing.

They pose gravely for me in their worn shawls. They are not interested in my sending them copies of their portraits. Another Indian mystery. Is it possible that just the moment of being photographed is enough for them? That that alone will do? No need to store up and hand down images, maya being maya?

I have given up hoping to turn over a stone and find a spiritual teacher in flower.

That affliction exhausted itself a long time ago. My camera has transformed me from seeker to sought. Boatmen, dhobis, women sculpting dung patties, all call to me, wave me over, want what I have to offer.

Photo by Ahron de Leeuw.

They slow me down. In Benares, foreigners move too quickly, either towards something or away from something, usually the crabbed beggar, the public defecator. Nothing edifying is ever asked of them.

Raising high my Minolta, I catch sadhus with tridents marching past children with cricket sticks. All along the ghats, like roadblocks, are cows the size of boxcars. An Indian magical realist might write: “It took me three days to get around them.”

Obstacles are part of what makes this city holy. Its holiness may be its biggest obstacle. It is harder to get around than the cows. The laurel of Shiva chafes. How much sanctity can one city take?

The heretic in me is pleased when the young man at Nishad Ghat tries to sell me hashish in full view of the Ganges. My first time here, another young man showed me his stash at the Burning Ghat.

“Hashish from Manali,” he entreated. “Best hashish.”

I turned him down. He wasn’t happy.

Photo by jpereira_net.

“No photo allowed here.” He rapped my camera with his knuckles. “This is holy place.”

They are the soul mates of the rickshaw driver, who while trying to cheat me, offers to find me a prostitute, as I am a man alone in Benares. I don’t photograph him, even though he is a souvenir of sorts. A resident of the city who has forgotten its story.

Or if he remembers it, he’s banished it to an island inside his brain, where it is kept in quarantine.

Cutting through a slum by the Malaviya Bridge, the corner of my eye is assaulted by a ferocious ochre glare. A holy man is looking into a mirror, getting himself ready for the day. Dipping his fingers into a bowl of ochre paste, his brow bends to receive its trident.

I want that shot. The mirror is the key. It echoes the fastidious lady in New York, getting herself ready for the day. But my courage fails me. I don’t want the sadhu to think me crass.

The image I leave there on the ground tumbles around inside me like a hungry ghost larger than myself.

I try to stay away from the Burning Ghat, gaudy with death for all its holiness. I used to spend long hours hypnotized by the fires, the circling of families around the fires, lost in the steps of their slow ancient dance. What moved in me as they were moving?

Photo by paolo bosonin.

What dance was I doing? And to what music?

When I find myself, as I do now, amidst the hive of temples, the racks of logs, the acrid plumes of smoke that burn my eyes, I am chastened by the dislocating sameness of the place. Why does nothing here seem to change when change is why this ghat is here?

From the rise above the clearing, a corpse, newly torched, is spitting flames into the living air. It came mummy-wrapped in saffron. Who? I wonder. In India, I always wonder, “Who?” to avoid being sucked into the what of human free-fall.

Judith shakes herself out of a deep sleep to shoot me a cross look from her end of the earth. Are you looking for the meaning of death in red flames leaping like circus acrobats from saffron bundles? Or are you just bored?

I return to Krishnamurti, where the Varuna River empties into the Ganges. India calls holy any confluence of two rivers. Bathers in dhotis are wading out to where the rivers meet. I take a photo and think of Judith. I think of her two rivers.

Community Connection

For more on India, please check here.


  • Stumble It

About the Author

Robert Hirschfield

Robert Hirschfield is a free-lance writer and photographer whose work appears in Ode Magazine, The National Catholic Reporter, Outlook (the Indian newsweekly), and the London Jewish Chronicle, among other publications. He has travelled most recently to north and South India, and to Israel and the West Bank.

12 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Tim Patterson replied on August 24, 2009

    Absolutely gorgeous writing. You brought me back to Varanasi. Thank you.

    ↵ Reply
  • Paul Sullivan replied on August 24, 2009

    Robert you are obviously a very poetic soul; your writing exudes a warm and alluring spirituality. Thanks for sharing this story…

    ↵ Reply
    • robert hirschfield replied to Paul Sullivan on August 28, 2009

      benares can make even a stone soulful.
      have you ever been there?
      i want to say thanks for your kind words.
      writing is done in solitude
      and the doing of it is reward enough.
      but hearing from a reader
      is always very exciting,
      and in the case of cyber responses mystifying
      as well. what corner of the world do you inhabit?

      thanks again
      robert

      ↵ Reply
  • joshywashington replied on August 24, 2009

    Such rich, textured writing is a treat.
    I would love to read more from Robert any day.

    ↵ Reply
    • robert hirschfield replied to joshywashington on August 28, 2009

      hi josh:

      sorry for this belated response.
      a writer writes for an invisible
      audience, and it’s nice to see
      the faces and read the words
      (especially words like yours)
      of readers.

      just finished a story today on
      nariman house in mumbai
      that matador will be publishing.

      thanks for your comment
      robert

      ↵ Reply
  • david miller replied on August 24, 2009

    “Obstacles are part of what makes this city holy. Its holiness may be its biggest obstacle.”

    Damn. Those are a couple of great lines, out of many.

    Thanks for this piece Robert. It’s beautiful.

    ↵ Reply
  • Michelle replied on August 24, 2009

    That was amazing. I finished this article with the same feeling I have when I’ve been lost in a great book for hours. Awesome.

    ↵ Reply
    • robert hirschfield replied to Michelle on August 28, 2009

      hi michelle:

      i think those may be the nicest words
      anyone has ever written about my
      writing. benares was one of those
      stories where the words do exactly
      what the writer wants them to do.
      MATADOR will be running my second story:
      it’s on nariman house in mumbai.

      what do you do when you are writing kind
      comments to authors?

      robert

      ↵ Reply
  • Candice replied on August 25, 2009

    I agee with Michelle, your writing is hypnotic.

    ↵ Reply
  • david miller replied on August 28, 2009

    just read the draft of robert’s next story and can’t wait to publish. should be up early next week.

    ↵ Reply
  • neha replied on August 29, 2009

    I started my Saturday morning with this. It has left me hypnotized, nostalgic, homesick, and a bunch of other emotions that will take too long to qualify! I can’t wait to read your next piece.

    ↵ Reply
  • kalista replied on September 4, 2009

    good writing, i enjoy reading

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Jump To Category:





Popular Stories on Matador

How to Move to Paris with No Money

This is for Americans with insufficient funds, but with... 

Hostel Sex: A Practical Guide For Backpackers

Getting it wherever a backpacker can...... 

10 Traveler's Tips For Rocking A Nudist Beach

Travelers tend to enjoy ultimate freedom on the road, t... 

12 Personal Travel Websites That Will Make You Quit Your Day Job

... 

Drunk and Driving On Berlin’s Beer Bike

Cars nervously skirt by the slowly moving vehicle, tour... 

10 Multi-Use Items You Should Consider Packing

... 



Focus



Editor Blogs