Coming to Goa for ‘None of the things Lonely Planet can offer me’

10/22/09  Print this post Print this post    4 Comments   Popular   Written by Robert Hirschfield
  • Stumble It

Girl in Goa, India. Photo: Steve Weaver

Robert Hirschfield digs through the layers at Baga, Goa.

Biting into my Mediterranean sandwich at Baba Au Rum (feta cheese, black olives, sun dried tomatoes spilling from the sides of French bread), I think of the party I went to last night at one of the Yoga centers around Baga.

A dressed-in-white party. No exceptions. Everywhere I looked, bleached figures were floating across the grounds like sleep walkers. It is easy to be cynical about Westerners in Goa.

I joke to Aimee Ginsburg, a Westerner from Israel: “A lot of people looking for the perfect spiritual beach.”

She is not amused. She has reason not to be. Israeli Goans, relative newcomers, are lassoed inside lazy clichés: burnt out cases, exiles from an endless war.

Baga’s winter guests, often heavyset blokes from the UK, here for the warm sun and drinks at the beach shacks, or maybe even visits with the healer Patrick at Nani and Rani’s, sail innocently beneath my radar. What is transitory, like this author eating his Mediterranean sandwich among Baga’s old-timers, does not demand to be taken seriously.

I am happy, momentarily, to be part of the legendary weave of Westerners in India’s smallest state, only recently pried loose from Portugal. (Indian Goans are said to see us more as a fungus than a weave.)

I see myself as exempt from the normal clichés that swirl around the spirit junkies and beach slaves. I have come to Goa for none of the things Lonely Planet can offer me. I admit I say this smugly.

The woman who lives two houses down from me is the reason I am here. Outside her house is her blue motor scooter with its head tilted, as if trying to make up its mind about something.

Community Connection

Please submit notes from the road to david [at] matadornetwork.com

For another interesting perspective on travelers in India, check out this piece at BNT by Rolf Potts.


  • Stumble It

About the Author

Robert Hirschfield

Robert Hirschfield is a free-lance writer and photographer whose work appears in Ode Magazine, The National Catholic Reporter, Outlook (the Indian newsweekly), and the London Jewish Chronicle, among other publications. He has travelled most recently to north and South India, and to Israel and the West Bank.

4 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Julie replied on October 22, 2009

    Fantastic! I love the tight brevity of this piece and how it builds up to an ending that gives away everything and nothing.

    ↵ Reply
  • Reeti replied on October 22, 2009

    Love your writing :)

    ↵ Reply
  • Lyn replied on October 25, 2009

    Really? That’s it? Yes, I love your writing too and i wanted more. I wanted a longer piece, more to read, more to get into.

    Great piece but cut short. Editors?

    ↵ Reply
  • Vikram replied on October 26, 2009

    Beautiful! Julie, above, is absolutely correct; ending gives away everything and nothing at the same time :)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Jump To Category:



Explore the Community


Latest Community Blogs

  • Commune with the gods of Where The Hell over at my column!......
    » posted on 18 November 2009
  • www.knkexplore.wordpress.comWelcome to the Midweek Snack, a weekly feature in which Rob and I will explore Peruvian cuis...
    » posted on 19 November 2009
  • We interrupt this burgeoning travel writing career to bring you the parental visit.  Tidy up all those random books...
    » posted on 18 November 2009

Popular Stories on Matador

How to Move to Paris with No Money

This is for Americans with insufficient funds, but with... 

Hostel Sex: A Practical Guide For Backpackers

Getting it wherever a backpacker can...... 

10 Traveler's Tips For Rocking A Nudist Beach

Travelers tend to enjoy ultimate freedom on the road, t... 

12 Personal Travel Websites That Will Make You Quit Your Day Job

... 

Drunk and Driving On Berlin’s Beer Bike

Cars nervously skirt by the slowly moving vehicle, tour... 

10 Multi-Use Items You Should Consider Packing

... 



Focus



Editor Blogs